Summary: Phoebe reunites with gay ice skater Duncan who she is married to. Duncan asks for a divorce as he wants to marry someone else and Phoebe is hurt but ultimately complies. The friends reveal big secrets about each other, with Chandler being revealed to have a third nipple and Joey having been in a porno movie. Ross asks Rachel for relationship advice and she tries to sabotage his relationship despite understanding how cruel it is.
The Good: This was a good episode. The best part was easily the secrets scene which was hilarious and so real. It was a brilliant use of all 6 major characters and provided one good laugh after the other. In fact the entire first part of this episode was brilliant and uniquely funny. There were great jokes consistently and the plot was created very logically and organically. It was half of an amazing episode, though unfortunately some of the later parts of the episode drag down the score (see: The Bad). Joey's porno was also a nice subplot and it made for a few good laughs. But it was Chandler's third nipple which provided the best jokes of the episode at a consistent rate.
The Bad: Phoebe's storyline is pretty bland. It felt like a poor attempt to make us feel something, and feels like a rip-off of Phoebe's storyline with David from "The One with the Monkey". Unfortunately this storyline isn't anywhere near as powerful or as funny so it really drags down the episode. Rachel sabotaging Ross wasn't very good either. Well it was funny, but it felt so extremely and unrealistically cruel for Rachel to go to such lengths to stop Ross and Julie's relationship. The problem is that Rachel is put in a positive light but it's hard to support her as she purposefully holds back Ross' relationship. Rachel was toeing the line in previous episodes but here she took a step too far. The quality drop in the episode actually really hurt the flow because it was so noticeable. This is the first episode of Friends where I really felt like time was being wasted on things that weren't that interesting in the second half.
Best Moment: The secrets revel scene was fantastic and one of the best scenes the show has provided so far. Great comedy.
Character of the Episode: Chandler.
Conclusion: The first half of this episode made me believe we would get a fantastic episode, but unfortunately the second half of the episode wasn't very funny and actually dragged on at times, which is rare for a sitcom. In the end, the episode is simply good.
Just a university student who loves to watch TV. And criticize it like hell.